"My roof is fine": an honest reply for roofing reps
A homeowner says the roof is fine. How roofing reps offer a free look without inventing damage, when to leave, and why nothing found is a good result.
Short answer: agree that they may well be right, offer an inspection with their permission, and report exactly what you find, including nothing. Never invent, cause or exaggerate damage. A roof that is fine is a good result for the homeowner, and an honest "I found nothing" is what makes the next neighbor open the door. The overview does not cover roofing, and the stakes are higher here because a bad inspection can become insurance fraud.
What they usually mean
- They cannot see a problem from the ground. Hail and wind damage is often invisible from the yard. A roof can leak or look worn before the homeowner notices.
- It really is fine. A newer roof or one nobody touched since the storm may have nothing wrong.
- They have heard the "storm chaser" story. They think you will find damage whether it exists or not. See the scam objection.
- They do not want a salesperson on the roof. That is a fair boundary.
How to answer
"You may be right, and I hope so. I'm checking roofs on this street because of the hail on [date]. Can I take a look from the yard, and with your permission up on the roof? If it's fine I'll tell you it's fine."
Use it first. It names the reason you are there (a real, dated storm, if there was one), and it gives them the result they want to hear if true. Do not claim a storm you cannot name.
"From the ground I can see [what you can actually see]. Whether there's anything on the shingles I can't say until I'm up there. It takes about [honest time], and I'll show you the photos."
Use it with someone open but unsure. Describe only what is visible. Photos you take must show the roof as it is. See roof inspection for what a proper one involves.
"No problem at all. If you ever see a stain on a ceiling or granules in the gutter, give me a call."
Use this when they decline. Leave a card with your name and the company's full name. It is not a trick to come back with.
What to do on the roof
Ask permission before you climb, and do not climb a roof in unsafe conditions. Photograph what is there, show the homeowner, and say in plain words what it means and what it does not. An old roof is not the same as a damaged roof. Wear is not storm damage. Whether something is covered by insurance is the insurer's call, not yours; if a claim might apply, see the claim objection.
What never to do
- Damage the roof, move shingles or exaggerate a photo. That is fraud.
- Say the roof "will fail soon" without a reason you can show.
- Offer a free roof or a free inspection that leads to a pressure sale. If an inspection is free, it must be free.
- Go on the roof after they said no.
How it differs from other industries
In roofing the thing being sold is something the owner cannot see or judge, so trust is the whole sale. In windows and siding and gutters the problem is visible from the yard, so the conversation can start with something they can see. Check state and city rules, which can include contractor licensing and limits on contracts; see the roofing rules by state.
When to thank them and leave
When they say no to an inspection, thank them and leave without a second pitch. When the inspection finds nothing, say so, thank them and go. The homeowner who got an honest "your roof is fine" is the best referral you will get on that street.
Questions
What do you say when a homeowner says their roof is fine?
Agree that it may be, name the real storm that brought you to the street, and offer a look with their permission. Report exactly what you find, including nothing, and leave a card if they decline.
Can a roofing rep climb on a roof without asking?
No. Get the homeowner's permission first and never go up after they decline. Do not climb in unsafe conditions. Photograph what is actually there and show the homeowner the photos in person.
What is insurance fraud in a roof inspection?
Causing, staging or exaggerating damage, or reporting damage that is not there, to support a claim. A rep who does that can lose their job and face legal trouble. Report only what you can see.
Is an old roof the same as a damaged roof?
No. Age and wear are different from storm damage. Say plainly which one you see. Whether either is covered by insurance is the insurer's decision, and a rep should not promise approval.
More objections
- "I'm Not Interested": How to Respond at the Door
- "I Need to Talk to My Spouse": How to Respond
- "I Need to Think About It": What to Say
- "I Already Have Someone": Door Response
- "It's Too Expensive": How to Respond at the Door
- "Just Send Me Information": How to Respond
- "I'm Busy": How to Handle a Bad Time at the Door
- No Soliciting Sign: What to Do at the Door
- "I'm Renting": What Renters Can Buy at the Door
- "I Do It Myself": Responding at the Door
- "I'm Under Contract" at the Door: Your Reply
- "Is This a Scam?" How to Answer at the Door
- "I Already Got Quotes": What to Say Next
- "My Electric Bill Is Low": A Solar Reply
- "I Don't Want to File a Claim": Roofing Reply
- "Come Back Later": How to Respond and Return
- "We're Moving Soon": What to Say at the Door
- "My Internet Is Fine": A Fiber Rep's Reply
- "I Need to Do Research First": Your Reply
- "I Already Have Insulation": How to Respond
- "We Have a Portable Generator": Your Reply
- "I'm Happy With My Trash Hauler": Response
- "My Basement Is Dry": How to Respond
- "I'll Paint It Myself": How to Respond
- "We Have a Lawn Guy": How to Respond
- "I Clean My Own Gutters": How to Respond
- "My HOA Won't Allow It": How to Respond
- "My Windows Are Fine": How to Respond
- "My House Is New": How to Respond
- Talking Through a Doorbell Camera: What to Do
- "I Don't Want a Contract": How to Respond
- All