Dealer vs. direct company: selling for a sales organization or for the provider itself
Short answer: A dealer, or sales organization, sells another company's product under contract and employs or contracts you itself. A direct company is the provider or installer, and you work for the brand on the product. Neither is automatically better. A dealer may offer a bigger team, a faster start and more ways to move up. A direct company may offer clearer terms and one fewer party between you and your commission. The right question is who signs your agreement and who pays you.
| Authorized dealer or sales organization | The provider or installer directly | |
|---|---|---|
| Who you work for | A sales organization with a contract to sell the provider's product | The provider or installer that delivers the product itself |
| Who signs your agreement | The dealer | The provider |
| Who pays you | The dealer, from commission it receives from the provider | The provider directly |
| What shapes your commission | The provider's rate, minus what each layer above you keeps, so two dealers selling the same product can pay differently | The provider's own plan, with fewer layers between you and the rate |
| Chargebacks and holdbacks | Set by the dealer's agreement, which may be stricter than the provider's own rules | Set by the provider; ask who decides when a sale counts as cancelled |
| Training and team | Often a large team, structured training and a route into team lead roles | Varies. Some provider teams are small; others are large and well trained |
| Product options | Some dealers sell for more than one provider, others for only one | One company's product |
| Stability | Depends on the dealer's contract; a lost contract can end the work | Depends on the provider's own plans in the area |
| Employment type | Employee or independent contractor, depending on the dealer | Employee or independent contractor, depending on the provider |
| What to confirm first | That the dealer is authorized by the provider, and who is responsible for permits and licensing | That the role is a sales role and not a subcontractor arrangement |
Choose authorized dealer or sales organization if
- You want a large team, structured training and a clear ladder into leading a team
- You are comfortable reading a dealer agreement closely before you sign
- You might like to sell more than one provider's product over time
- You want to join an organization that has hired many new reps
Choose the provider or installer directly if
- You want to know exactly who the product, the contract and the pay plan come from
- You prefer one fewer layer between you and your commission
- You care about working for the brand you sell
- You like to deal with the same company from knock to install
How reps move between the two
Reps move between the two, and a rep who sells well for a dealer is often recruited by the provider, or the reverse. Read the non-compete in your agreement before you do. Some contracts limit where and for whom you can sell after you leave.
When you switch, ask what happens to the commission on sales that have not yet completed. In a dealer arrangement, unpaid commission may be tied to the dealer's relationship with the provider. In a direct arrangement, it is tied to the provider's own pay schedule.
Questions
What is the difference between a dealer and a direct sales company?
A dealer is an organization that sells another company's product under contract, and it recruits, trains and pays the reps. A direct company is the provider or installer, which employs or contracts the reps itself. The main difference for you is who signs your agreement and pays you.
Is it better to work for a dealer or for the company directly?
Neither is always better. A dealer may offer a larger team and a quicker start. A direct company may offer clearer terms. Compare the commission rate, holdbacks and chargeback rules in writing, and ask who is responsible if a sale cancels after you are paid.
How do I know if a dealer is authorized to sell a company's product?
Ask the dealer to name the provider it sells for and ask for written proof of the relationship, then confirm with the provider if you can. An unauthorized seller can leave you unpaid. Our guide to vetting a door-to-door sales company lists what to ask.
Read next
- How to Vet a Door-to-Door Sales Company
- Door-to-Door Rep Agreement Checklist
- How Door-to-Door Sales Pay Works
- Leaving a Door-to-Door Sales Company
Terms used on this page
More comparisons
- Fiber sales vs. solar sales
- Pest control sales vs. fiber sales
- Solar sales vs. roofing sales
- Pest control sales vs. home security sales
- Door-to-door sales vs. inside sales
- Commission only vs. base plus commission
- Traveling sales vs. local sales
- Fiber sales vs. home security sales
- Solar sales vs. pest control sales
- Fiber sales vs. cable and wireless sales
- Summer sales vs. year-round sales
- Door-to-door sales vs. business field sales
- Employee sales jobs vs. contractor sales jobs
- Roofing sales vs. pest control sales
- Home security sales vs. solar sales
- Fiber sales vs. roofing sales
- Door-to-door sales vs. retail sales
- Door-to-door sales vs. car sales
- Door-to-door sales vs. insurance sales
- Summer sales vs. internship
- Door-to-door sales vs. gig driving
- Door-to-door sales vs. network marketing (multi-level marketing)
- Door-to-door sales vs. real estate
- Roofing sales vs. home security sales
- Door-to-door sales vs. tech sales
- Setter vs. closer